Obeahman's Killings

The Obeahman has killed many people and most importantly, killed Cassio’s father, pursuing him to be a ghost hunter. Some of them he did not kill himself, but rather absorbed their power from when Cas had stabbed, sliced or cut them with his athame.

List of Murders
Since the Obeahman is an ‘Eater of flesh’ most of his living victims were found to have giant bite-marks and chunks missing from their bodies.

Mr Lowood
Cas’s father was killed by the Obeahman, when he went to destroy him, thinking that he was a ghost. Instead the Obeahman ate his father alive, instantly linking himself to the athame, which might have been caused when his father may or may not have stabbed him.

Will Rosenberg
Will was found dead in his bedroom, when Cas and Thomas went to take back Cas’s athame. He also had giant bite marks all over his body.

Chase Putnam
Chase was also found in Will’s bedroom at the same time Will was found. Unluckily for him, the Obeahman also took huge chunks out of Chase too.

Tybalt
At some point when Cas and his mother were both gone, Tybalt the cat had climbed into the attic and was eaten by the Obeahman. It was also noted that the Obeahman had Tybalt's tail wrapped around his fingers and when Cas was fighting the Obeahman in Girl of Nightmares, Tybalt might have been set free because Cas supposedly saw a tail when he was freeing the victims.

Jogger
After Wills tole the athame, and the very next day Anna was set free, a jogger was found in a park in Thunder Bay. Cas witnessed police and the paramedics carry eaten body parts, covered with tarps back to the paramedic’s van.